Stop Leaving Money on the Table: Why Most Business Owners Are Terrible at Client Negotiations

Connect with us: Medium | Pexels | Doodle or Die | SB Nation | Komoot

Mate, I'm going to start with something that'll probably ruffle a few feathers: if you're not walking away from at least 20% of potential deals, you're not negotiating hard enough.

There. I said it.

After seventeen years of watching small business owners bend over backwards for every client who walks through their door, I've seen more money left on boardroom tables than most people earn in a lifetime. And the worst part? It's completely preventable.

Last month, I watched a plumbing contractor in Geelong quote $3,200 for a bathroom renovation, only to immediately drop to $2,600 when the client winced. Not because the client said anything. Not because they threatened to walk. Because the tradie panicked at a facial expression.

That's not negotiation. That's desperation wearing a high-vis vest.

The Uncomfortable Truth About Australian Business Culture

We've got this bizarre cultural thing where we think being a "good bloke" means giving everyone the best possible deal. It's killing our profit margins and honestly, it's not doing our clients any favours either.

Here's something that might shock you: clients respect you more when you hold firm on pricing. I know, I know. Sounds counterintuitive. But think about it from their perspective – would you trust a surgeon who immediately offered to cut their fee in half? Of course not.

The same psychology applies to your business, whether you're laying concrete in Cairns or consulting on cybersecurity in Canberra.

But here's where most people get it wrong. They think negotiation is about being aggressive or manipulative. Complete bollocks. Real negotiation is about understanding what everyone actually wants and finding creative ways to deliver value.

The Three Things No One Tells You About Client Psychology

First thing: clients expect to negotiate. When you don't give them any room to move, they feel like they're missing out on something. It's like going to Bali and paying the first price at the markets – feels wrong, doesn't it?

Second: price is rarely the real issue. I've seen businesses lose contracts because they focused only on dollars while their competitor offered better payment terms, faster delivery, or ongoing support. Yet somehow we always default to cutting our rates.

Third, and this one's important: difficult clients who negotiate hard often become your best long-term customers. They're engaged, they know what they want, and they're less likely to cause scope creep later.

Why Your "Standard Process" Is Costing You Money

Most businesses approach negotiations like they're reading from a script. Client objects to price, you offer a 10% discount. Client wants changes, you accommodate for free. Client delays payment, you just wait it out.

Wrong, wrong, and spectacularly wrong.

Every negotiation should be treated like a puzzle where both sides have pieces the other needs. Your client might need faster delivery more than they need a lower price. You might prefer upfront payment over a higher total fee. But you'll never discover these opportunities if you're just following a standard playbook.

I learned this the hard way about eight years ago. Had a client who kept pushing back on our training rates for their sales team. Kept offering discounts, getting nowhere. Finally asked what was really driving their concern. Turns out they were worried about budget approval timelines, not the actual amount.

Split the payment across two financial years, same total price, everyone happy. That one conversation changed how I approach every negotiation since.

The Active Listening Trap (And How to Avoid It)

Now, before someone in the comments starts banging on about active listening skills, let me save you some time. Yes, listening is important. But there's a difference between understanding what someone is saying and letting them walk all over you.

Active listening in negotiation means hearing what's not being said. When a client says "your price is too high," they might actually mean "I need to justify this expense to my board" or "I'm comparing you to someone who's quoting apples to your oranges."

The trick is asking questions that get to the real issue. "Compared to what?" is one of my favourites. Or "what would need to change for this to work within your budget?"

Setting Boundaries That Actually Stick

Here's where I see most Australian business owners completely lose their spine. They negotiate beautifully, reach an agreement, then let the client chip away at it over the following weeks.

Scope creep is not inevitable weather. It's a choice you make when you don't enforce the boundaries you've set.

I've got a client in Melbourne (won't name names, but they're in logistics) who used to be chronic for this. We'd agree on a project scope, then they'd add "just one small thing" every week. Turned a three-month engagement into seven months of frustration.

Solution was embarrassingly simple. Started charging a change request fee for any modifications after the contract was signed. Not to be punitive, but to make them think twice. Funny how those "urgent" changes became much less urgent when they had a price tag attached.

The Payment Terms Game-Changer

Most people negotiate on price and completely ignore payment terms. Massive mistake. A 30-day payment cycle versus 60 days can be worth more than a 10% discount, especially for cash flow.

But here's where it gets interesting: many larger clients prefer longer payment terms and will pay a premium for them. Government contracts, mining companies, major retailers – they often have complex approval processes that make quick payments difficult.

Rather than fighting this, build it into your pricing structure. Offer different rates for different payment schedules. 14 days? Standard rate. 60 days? Add 8%. Net 90? Add 15%.

Suddenly you're not competing on price alone, you're offering flexible commercial terms that solve real business problems.

When to Walk Away (And How to Do It Right)

This is the bit that separates the pros from the amateurs. Knowing when to walk away, and doing it gracefully.

If someone's asking you to cut your margins to the bone just to win the business, run. If they're making unreasonable demands before you've even started working together, imagine what they'll be like three months in.

But walking away doesn't mean burning bridges. I've had clients come back eighteen months later with proper budgets and realistic expectations because I didn't cave the first time around.

The key is making it about fit, not judgment. "I don't think we're the right match for this project" works better than "your budget is ridiculous."

Common Negotiation Mistakes That Kill Deals

Talking too much. Seriously, shut up. Ask a question, then wait for the answer. I've watched salespeople talk themselves out of closed deals because they couldn't handle the silence.

Making price the first conversation. Lead with value, outcomes, results. Price should be the natural conclusion of a conversation about what you're delivering, not the opening gambit.

Accepting "maybe" as an answer. Maybe is not a decision, it's an avoidance tactic. Push for clarity: "What would need to happen for this to be a yes?"

Getting emotional. The moment you take negotiation personally, you've lost. It's business, not personal validation.

The Follow-Up Framework

Once you've reached an agreement, confirm everything in writing immediately. Not next week, not when you get around to it. Immediately.

Detail what was agreed, when it starts, payment terms, deliverables, and crucially, what happens if things change. Clear expectations prevent most conflicts down the track.

I use a simple template that covers:

• Scope of work
• Timeline and milestones
• Payment schedule
• Change request process
• Cancellation terms

Nothing fancy, just clear communication that keeps everyone on the same page.

Advanced Techniques for Complex Negotiations

For bigger deals, consider bringing in external negotiation expertise. Sounds expensive, but a good negotiation workshop can pay for itself with the first major contract you don't botch.

Package deals work brilliantly for ongoing relationships. Instead of negotiating every individual project, create annual retainers or multi-project agreements that give clients predictability and you consistent revenue.

Risk-sharing arrangements can unlock deals where budget is genuinely tight. Performance bonuses, success fees, or equity stakes in appropriate situations.

The Long Game Perspective

Here's something most people miss: negotiation skills compound over time. Every conversation you have builds your confidence and understanding of what works in your industry.

Track your results. Which approaches lead to better margins? Which clients become long-term relationships? What objections keep coming up, and how can you address them proactively?

For sales-focused roles, structured training in negotiating for sales results can dramatically improve outcomes. But the real learning happens in practice, deal after deal.

Technology and Modern Negotiations

CRM systems can track negotiation patterns and outcomes, helping you identify what works. Video calls have changed the dynamics – easier to read body language than phone calls, but different from face-to-face meetings.

Electronic signatures speed up the closing process, but don't rush people through decisions. The goal is efficiency, not pressure.

Industry-Specific Considerations

Construction and trades: Material